Piston or diaphragm: Does it matter?

Text by Francois Burman, Pr. Eng., M.Sc.
Photo's by Stephen Frink
First-stage scuba regulators convert high pressure to intermediate pressure and must deliver gas at a constant intermediate pressure, relative to depth, to the second stage for divers to breathe easily. To maintain constant delivery despite changes in water conditions, depth, breathing needs and pressure in a scuba cylinder, first stages have a sensing mechanism that adjusts to these changes, allowing for constant pressure and delivery regardless of the conditions.
There are two main ways for these devices to respond to changes in supply pressure, demand and depth in real time. Diaphragm-sensed regulators use a flexible element to adjust to these changes and to ensure constant outlet pressure and flow relative to depth; piston-sensed regulators use a sliding metallic piston that moves to adapt to these variations.
Some divers think that piston regulators are lighter, smaller, and more reliable, robust and sensitive to changes. Some believe they perform better at depth, accommodate greater gas flow, function more reliably in freezing conditions and are cheaper to maintain despite initially being more expensive. Those who prefer piston regulators claim they are a better value for their money than any diaphragm product.
Other divers swear by diaphragm regulators, finding them to be superior in terms of all the above-stated advantages. Traditionally, diaphragm regulators are sealed from the environment to reduce the likelihood of any internal corrosion or freezing in cold water.
The truth is that modern, good-quality regulators are designed, machined and built so well that the limitations and bad experiences of the past are no longer the reality. Personal preference, rather than operational capacity, now governs divers’ decisions. The average diver would likely be unable to discern a difference in performance between the two types of regulators in most types of diving. If your regulator type suits you, then stay with it. If you are purchasing a new regulator, you may want to consider how you will be using it before making your final decision.
Think about what kinds of diving you intend to do, ask questions, and research recommendations based on your intended activities. Try several regulators if you can, and then get the one that performs best for you. For 90 percent of diving activities, the regulator type does not matter. If you will occasionally be diving where a specific regulator type may be advised based on the environment, then you can always rent something more suitable for those specific conditions.
For example, strenuous diving at depths below 300 feet may raise concerns about gas flow. Inquire about a regulator’s performance being able to meet the maximum demand without affecting ease of breathing. Similarly, if you dive where surface temperatures are freezing, choose a regulator rated to perform at those surface and underwater temperatures without seizing up.
Divers who migrate from air to gas mixtures, especially with oxygen varying from hypoxic levels to pure oxygen, should select a regulator that is compatible and safe for use with elevated oxygen levels. Check for this certification and rating with the dealer or manufacturer.
Regardless of which type of first stage you choose, follow the manufacturer’s guidelines for use and maintenance. Failing to follow the manufacturer’s requirements to regularly service the regulator or using spare parts not provided or approved by the manufacturer will void any warranties or certifications. Such negligence could be a contributing factor to a regulator failure, regardless of type.
Some divers use compressed gas to blow off the inlet to the regulator after the dive or after rinsing the regulator. Doing that will simply blow water and any other debris into the regulator and may make the seat fair game for damage, corrosion and potential leaking or seizing, regardless of the regulator type. To prolong the life of your regulator, use a microfiber towel to clean the regulator inlet and the dust cap, which ensures optimal reliability and preserves your regulator (along with the hearing of those around you).
Regulator reliability and lifespan are almost entirely dependent on human elements such as proper use and maintenance, not regulator design or configuration. When purchasing a new first stage, do not base your decision on whether it has a piston or a diaphragm. Choose the one you like that is the best suited for your preferred type of diving, and follow the manufacturer’s recommendations for care and service. AD
Photo's by Stephen Frink
First-stage scuba regulators convert high pressure to intermediate pressure and must deliver gas at a constant intermediate pressure, relative to depth, to the second stage for divers to breathe easily. To maintain constant delivery despite changes in water conditions, depth, breathing needs and pressure in a scuba cylinder, first stages have a sensing mechanism that adjusts to these changes, allowing for constant pressure and delivery regardless of the conditions.
There are two main ways for these devices to respond to changes in supply pressure, demand and depth in real time. Diaphragm-sensed regulators use a flexible element to adjust to these changes and to ensure constant outlet pressure and flow relative to depth; piston-sensed regulators use a sliding metallic piston that moves to adapt to these variations.
Some divers think that piston regulators are lighter, smaller, and more reliable, robust and sensitive to changes. Some believe they perform better at depth, accommodate greater gas flow, function more reliably in freezing conditions and are cheaper to maintain despite initially being more expensive. Those who prefer piston regulators claim they are a better value for their money than any diaphragm product.
Other divers swear by diaphragm regulators, finding them to be superior in terms of all the above-stated advantages. Traditionally, diaphragm regulators are sealed from the environment to reduce the likelihood of any internal corrosion or freezing in cold water.
The truth is that modern, good-quality regulators are designed, machined and built so well that the limitations and bad experiences of the past are no longer the reality. Personal preference, rather than operational capacity, now governs divers’ decisions. The average diver would likely be unable to discern a difference in performance between the two types of regulators in most types of diving. If your regulator type suits you, then stay with it. If you are purchasing a new regulator, you may want to consider how you will be using it before making your final decision.
Think about what kinds of diving you intend to do, ask questions, and research recommendations based on your intended activities. Try several regulators if you can, and then get the one that performs best for you. For 90 percent of diving activities, the regulator type does not matter. If you will occasionally be diving where a specific regulator type may be advised based on the environment, then you can always rent something more suitable for those specific conditions.
For example, strenuous diving at depths below 300 feet may raise concerns about gas flow. Inquire about a regulator’s performance being able to meet the maximum demand without affecting ease of breathing. Similarly, if you dive where surface temperatures are freezing, choose a regulator rated to perform at those surface and underwater temperatures without seizing up.
Divers who migrate from air to gas mixtures, especially with oxygen varying from hypoxic levels to pure oxygen, should select a regulator that is compatible and safe for use with elevated oxygen levels. Check for this certification and rating with the dealer or manufacturer.
Regardless of which type of first stage you choose, follow the manufacturer’s guidelines for use and maintenance. Failing to follow the manufacturer’s requirements to regularly service the regulator or using spare parts not provided or approved by the manufacturer will void any warranties or certifications. Such negligence could be a contributing factor to a regulator failure, regardless of type.
Some divers use compressed gas to blow off the inlet to the regulator after the dive or after rinsing the regulator. Doing that will simply blow water and any other debris into the regulator and may make the seat fair game for damage, corrosion and potential leaking or seizing, regardless of the regulator type. To prolong the life of your regulator, use a microfiber towel to clean the regulator inlet and the dust cap, which ensures optimal reliability and preserves your regulator (along with the hearing of those around you).
Regulator reliability and lifespan are almost entirely dependent on human elements such as proper use and maintenance, not regulator design or configuration. When purchasing a new first stage, do not base your decision on whether it has a piston or a diaphragm. Choose the one you like that is the best suited for your preferred type of diving, and follow the manufacturer’s recommendations for care and service. AD
Posted in Alert Diver Summer Editions, Dive Safety Tips
Tagged with Regulators, Diaphragms, Pistons, Maintenance, Gear Servicing, Francois Burman
Tagged with Regulators, Diaphragms, Pistons, Maintenance, Gear Servicing, Francois Burman
Categories
2021
March
Old Habits Die HardSave a Diver, Save YourselfCylinder SafetyUndercover CrabsReef safe sunscreenPhysics, Biophysics and Decompression SicknessModels and Marine LifeSunscreen and CoralCristina Mittermeier: Commitment to ConservationDiving After a StrokeCurrent DivesThis Bites: Prevention TreatmentEnvironmental Considerations for Disinfection
2020
January
February
Group Fitness at the PoolHow to Rescue a Distressed diver at the SurfaceHow to manage Near-DrowningNo Sit-ups no problem How to manage MalariaHow to manage Oxygen Deficiency (Hypoxia)What to do when confronted by a sharkHow to manage Scombroid PoisoningHow to perform a Deep Diver RescueHow to perform One-rescuer CPRHow to perform a Neurological Assessment
March
DAN’s Quick Guide to Properly Disinfecting Dive GearCOVID-19 : Prevention Recommendations for our Diving CommunityGermophobia? - Just give it a reasonable thoughtScuba Equipment care – Rinsing and cleaning diving equipmentCOVID-19 and DAN MembershipFurther limitations imposed on travels and considerations on diving activitiesDAN Membership COVID-19 FAQsLancet COVID-19 South African Testing SitesCOVID-19 No Panic Help GuideGetting Decompression Sickness while FreedivingDown in the DumpsCardiovascular Disease and DivingDelayed Off-GassingDiving after Dental surgeryDiving with Multiple MedicationsPygmy Seahorses: Life AquaticAfrica DustCOVID-19 Myth BustersScuba Units Are Not Suitable Substitutes for VentilatorsDisinfection of Scuba Equipment and COVID-19Physioball Stability Exercises
April
COVID-19 AdvisoryScuba Equipment Care - Drying & Storing Your GearTransporting Diving Lights & BatteriesHow to Pivot Your Message During a CrisisTourism Relief FundCOVID-19 Business Support ReviewDiving After COVID-19: What We Know TodayEUBS-ECHM Position Statement on Diving ActivitiesPart 2: COVID-19 Business Support ReviewPress Release
May
Diving in the Era of COVID-19Dive Operations and COVID-19: Prepping for ReturnCOVID-19 & Diving Activities: 10 Safety RecommendationsCOVID-19: Surface Survival TimesThe Philippines at its FinestThe Logistics of ExplorationThe Art of the Underwater SelfieShooter: Douglas SeifertFAQs Answered: Disinfecting Scuba EquipmentStock your First-Aid KitResearch and OutreachCovid-19 ResearchOut of the BlueEffects of Aspirin on DivingThe New Pointy end of DivingDiving and Hepatitis CCaissons, Compressed-Air work and Deep TunnellingPreparing to Dive in the New NormalNew Health Declaration Form Sample Addressing C-19 IssuesDiving After COVID 19: What Divers Need to Know
June
Travel Smarter: PRE-TRIP VACCINATIONSAttention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder and DivingCOVID-19: Updated First Aid Training Recommendations From DANDiving with a Purpose in National Marine SanctuariesStay Positive Through the PandemicFor the Dive Operator: How to Protect Your Staff & ClientsStudying Deep reefs and Deep diversAsking the Right QuestionsLung squeeze under cold diving conditions
July
Dive DeprivationVolunteer Fish Surveys: Engage DiversDAN Member Profile: Mehgan Heaney-GrierTravel Smarter: Don’t Cancel, Reschedule InsteadDive Boat Fire SafetyRay of HopePartner ExercisesDiving at AltitudeAluminium ExposureHip FracturesAcoustic NeuromaGuidelines for Lifelong Medical Fitness to DiveNew Dive Medical Forms
August
Women in Diving: Lauren Arthur, Conservationist & Natural History Story TellerWomen in Diving: Dr Sara Andreotti White Shark ResearcherTiming ExerciseWomen in Diving: The Salty Wanderer, Charlie WarlandWomen in Diving: Beth Neale, Aqua soul of freedivingWomen in Diving: Diving and spearfishing Diva, Jean HattinghWomen in Diving: Zandile Ndhlovu, The Black Mermaid
September
October
Freediving For ScienceStep Exercises with CardioFluorescence Imaging help Identify Coral BleachingChildren and DivingThe Watchman device and divingScuba Diving and Factor V Leiden gene mutationNitrogen Narcosis at shallow depthsOil and Particulates: Safe levels in Breathing Air at depthDive Principles for Coping with COVID-19The Importance of a Predive Safety CheckTalya Davidoff: the 'Plattelandse Meisie' Freediver
2019
February
April
May
DAN Press ReleaseYour Dive Computer: Tips and tricks - PART 1Your Dive Computer: Tips and tricks - PART 2Aural HygieneDCS AheadHow Divers Can Help with coral conservationRed Tide and shellfish poisoningDiving after Kidney DonationDiving with hypertrophic cardiomyopathyEmergency Underwater Oxygen Recompression
June
July
September
October
November
Exercise drills with DowelsHeart-rate TrainingCultivating ConservationTRavel Smarter : Evaluating an unfamiliar Dive operatorChallenging the Frontiers of Decompression ResearchTravel Smarter: Plan for Medical EmergenciesWhen should I call my Doctor?DAN Student Medical Expense CoverageAdvice, Support and a LifelineWetsuits and heat stressDiving after Chiropractic adjustments
2018
April
Flying after pool diving FAQLung squeeze while freediving FAQDiving after Bariatric surgery FAQMarine injuries FAQVasovagal Syncope unpredictable FAQIncident report procedure FAQDiving after knee surgery FAQDiving when in RemissionDive with orbital Implant FAQInert gas washout FAQOxygen ears FAQPost Decompression sicknessChildren and diving. The real concerns.Diving after SurgeryPhysiology of Decompresssion sickness FAQDiving and regular exerciseGordon Hiles - I am an Underwater Cameraman and Film MakerScuba Air QualityBreath-hold diving. Part 3: The Science Bit!Compensation Legislation and the Recreational DiverCape Town DivingFive pro tips for capturing better images in cold waterThe Boat Left Without You: Now What?
May
When things go wrongEmergency Planning: Why Do We Need It?Breath-hold diving: Running on reserve -Part 5 Learning to RebreatheSweet Dreams: When Can I Resume Diving Post Anaesthesia?Investing in the future of reefsTo lie or not to lie?THE STORY OF A RASH AFTER A DIVEFirst Aid KitsTaravana: Fact or Falacy?
June
Oxygen Unit MaintenanceKnow Your Oxygen-Delivery Masks 1Know Your Oxygen-Delivery Masks 2Emergency Oxygen unitsInjuries due to exposure - HypothermiaInjuries due to exposure - Altitude sicknessInjuries due to Exposure - Dehydration and other concernsHow to plan for your dive tripThe Future of Dive MedicinePlastic is Killing our ocean
September
Return to DivingDiagnoses: Pulmonary blebSide effects of Rectogesic ointmentDiving with ChemotherapyReplacing dive computers and BCDsCustomize Your First-Aid KitPlan for medical emergenciesHow the dive Reflex protects the brain and heartDry suits and skin BendsAltitude sickness and DCSScuba Diving and Life Expectancy
2017
March
April
Incident Insight: TriageA Field Guide to Minor MishapsSnorkels: Pros & ConsTime & RecoveryMedication & Drug UseDiving with CancerNitrox FAQCOPD FAQHyperbaric Chamber FAQJet Lag FAQHydration FAQAnticoagulant Medication FAQFluid in the Ear FAQEye Surgery FAQElderly Divers FAQNitrogen FAQHealth Concerns FAQMotion Sickness FAQMicronuclei FAQ
June
August
2016
February
March
Breath-Hold Diving & ScubaReturn to Diving After DCITiming Exercise & DivingHot Tubs After DivingSubcutaneous EmphysemaIn-Water RecompressionDiving at AltitudeFlying After DivingDiving After FlyingThe Risks of Diabetes & DivingFlu-like Symptoms Following a DiveHand & Foot EdemaFrontal HeadachesBladder DiscomfortLatex AllergiesRemember to BreatheProper Position for Emergency CareAches & PainsCell Phones While DrivingSurfers Ear Ear Ventilation TubesDealing with Ear ProblemsDiving with Existing Ear InjuriesPerforated Ear DrumENT SurgeryUnpluggedCochlear ImplantsPortuguese Man-of-WarJellyfish StingsLionfish, Scorpionfish & Stonefish EnvenomationsStingray Envenomation Coral Cuts, Scrapes and RashesSpeeding & Driving Behaviour
June
Newsflash! Low Pressure Hose DeteriorationItching & rash go away & come back!7 Things we did not know about the oceanMigraine HeadacheAttention Deficit Disorder Cerebral Vascular AccidentEpilepsyCerebral PalsyHistory of SeizuresMultiple Sclerosis Head TraumaBreast Cancer & Fitness to Dive IssuesLocal Allergic ReactionsSea LiceHow ocean pollution affects humans Dive Fatality & Lobster Mini-Season StatisticsPregnancy & DivingReturn to Diving After Giving BirthBreast Implants & DivingMenstruation During Diving ActivitiesOral Birth ControlBreast FeedingPremenstrual SyndromeOsteoporosisThe Aftermath of Diving IncidentsCompensation Legislation & the Recreational DiverNoise-Induced Hearing LossLegal MattersThe Nature of Liability & DivingDAN Legal NetworkWaivers, Children & Solo DivingHealthy, but overweight!Taking Medication while Scuba DivingGetting Fit for the Dive SeasonBone Considerations in Young DiversAsthma and Scuba DivingHepatitisDiving with HyperglycemiaShoulder PainDiving After Spinal Back Surgery
August
Hazard Identification & Risk AssessmentCaring For Your People Caring For Your FacilitiesCaring For Your BusinessScuba Air Quality Part 1Scuba Air Quality Part 2Chamber Maintenance Part 1Chamber Maintenance Part 2The Aging Diver Propeller SafetyRelease The PressureDon't Get LostMore Water, Less Bubbles13 Ways to Run Out of Air & How Not To7 Mistakes Divers Make & How To Avoid ThemSafety Is In The AirHow Good Is Your Emergency Plan
2015
January
March