The Paper Nautilus

Above: The mature female argos will stack together during a mating or spawning event, forming chains of 10 or more. This photo was taken on an evening charged with activity at the height of the spawning season.
Text and photos by Mike Bartick
One evening during a surface interval at Janao Bay, Philippines, I was talking with our boat captain, a local, generational fisherman. We speak the minimum of each other’s language, so there was usually more smiling and laughing than actual conversing. As he told me about the different areas where they used to fish over the years, he mentioned a recent fishing ban on nautiluses. At that time I knew only about the chambered nautiluses that live at extreme depths, so I was a bit surprised.
I asked for more information and learned about how they would catch the nautiluses at shallow depths. “Not deep, just there,” he said, grabbing my attention and piquing my curiosity as he pointed to the water just around our boat. Why would nautiluses come to the shallows? Perhaps I wasn’t fully understanding the conversation.
When I returned to land later that night and began searching for information, I soon realized the captain had been referring to the paper nautilus, not the chambered nautilus. Paper nautiluses (Argonauta spp.), also known as argonauts, come to the surface at night to mate and to trap air in their shells to use for buoyancy. In doing so, they expose themselves to fishermen.
Continuing my research, I noted a single sentence on the Tree of Life Web Project site (tolweb.org/Argonauta) that made me realize something about the argonauts I had overlooked: “Males have been reported living within salps.” I looked through my images and realized that I had been seeing and photographing the male paper nautilus for the past several months without even realizing it. What I had assumed were ordinary larval octopuses sheltering in the salps were actually males of a species of paper nautilus (Argonauta hians), which don’t have a shell.
The paper nautilus is a pelagic octopus in the family Argonautidae. Researchers disagree about the number of distinct extant species, but the most commonly accepted are Argonauta argo, Argonauta hians, Argonauta nodosus and Argonauta nouryi. Many known species in this family are now extinct.
Only females produce the argonaut’s paper-thin shell, a tough calcite compound that they secrete from their two dorsal tentacles and use as an eggcase for brooding. Nautiluses can quickly jet-propel themselves through the water, making it difficult to photograph them — like trying to photograph a butterfly while running down the street.
The photogenic females have huge, well-developed eyes; they look like beardless gnomes with their bodies tucked into their hatlike shells. Full-grown females typically measure about 4 inches, while mature males are less than 1/4 inch. While a size difference between genders (sexual dimorphism) is common in nature, the drastic disparity between male and female argonauts is unusual.
A drop in the water temperature each year ushers in the argonaut mating season. As the water cools, divers can see the number of male argonauts in the water column dramatically increase from one or two to 20 or more on a single dive. In the black of night, the males buzz around like swarms of tiny bumblebees as they search for a mate.
Sexually mature females tend to be a bit shy during the off season, when the number of sightings are minimal. In contrast, mating season happens quickly, going from a single sighting one night to multiple sightings the next as the females begin to form groups. When the beams from our dive lights pass through a group of females, they instantly scatter and shoot toward us like kamikazes, running into our cameras and heads, bouncing off and rocketing toward the surface.
Both males and females ride jellyfish, salps and other objects such as leaves, sticks and even drifting debris. Researchers have found bits of jellyfish and salp in the stomachs of nautiluses, indicating that these cephalopods can survive in the water column by feeding on plankton and other mollusks or near substrate by feeding on shrimp and crabs. Like other species of octopus, argonauts possess a venom that is passed through their saliva when they use their beaks to kill their prey.
For the best chance to see a nautilus in the wild, be in the water at night in an area where they are usually found. It might require multiple dives at different times of the year — and a little bit of luck — to see one.
CAPTURING THE SHOT
When photographing argonauts, I prefer to use a 60mm lens, ISO 400, 1/200 shutter speed and the aperture at f/18. I set my strobes at half power and position them close to the lens port.
When framing the image, watch the argonauts’ eyes for sharp contact, and be prepared to swim quickly. Argonauts are light sensitive — using a red light can help calm them down, although it is not always necessary. Using a handheld light with a tight beam can help you see through turbid water. Refrain from touching the animals; they stress easily and like most cephalopods will ink profusely.
The argonaut is now a highly valued species for blackwater divers. Given the number of paper nautiluses we have seen in such a short time, the once-rare and unique subject has become more common.
Although sightings of paper nautiluses are on the rise, they are still one of nature’s biggest mysteries and have gone mostly unnoticed for a long time. Argonauts are a fascinating spectacle and will likely leave you as they have left me: in awe of nature. AD
Text and photos by Mike Bartick
One evening during a surface interval at Janao Bay, Philippines, I was talking with our boat captain, a local, generational fisherman. We speak the minimum of each other’s language, so there was usually more smiling and laughing than actual conversing. As he told me about the different areas where they used to fish over the years, he mentioned a recent fishing ban on nautiluses. At that time I knew only about the chambered nautiluses that live at extreme depths, so I was a bit surprised.
I asked for more information and learned about how they would catch the nautiluses at shallow depths. “Not deep, just there,” he said, grabbing my attention and piquing my curiosity as he pointed to the water just around our boat. Why would nautiluses come to the shallows? Perhaps I wasn’t fully understanding the conversation.
When I returned to land later that night and began searching for information, I soon realized the captain had been referring to the paper nautilus, not the chambered nautilus. Paper nautiluses (Argonauta spp.), also known as argonauts, come to the surface at night to mate and to trap air in their shells to use for buoyancy. In doing so, they expose themselves to fishermen.
Continuing my research, I noted a single sentence on the Tree of Life Web Project site (tolweb.org/Argonauta) that made me realize something about the argonauts I had overlooked: “Males have been reported living within salps.” I looked through my images and realized that I had been seeing and photographing the male paper nautilus for the past several months without even realizing it. What I had assumed were ordinary larval octopuses sheltering in the salps were actually males of a species of paper nautilus (Argonauta hians), which don’t have a shell.
The paper nautilus is a pelagic octopus in the family Argonautidae. Researchers disagree about the number of distinct extant species, but the most commonly accepted are Argonauta argo, Argonauta hians, Argonauta nodosus and Argonauta nouryi. Many known species in this family are now extinct.
Only females produce the argonaut’s paper-thin shell, a tough calcite compound that they secrete from their two dorsal tentacles and use as an eggcase for brooding. Nautiluses can quickly jet-propel themselves through the water, making it difficult to photograph them — like trying to photograph a butterfly while running down the street.
The photogenic females have huge, well-developed eyes; they look like beardless gnomes with their bodies tucked into their hatlike shells. Full-grown females typically measure about 4 inches, while mature males are less than 1/4 inch. While a size difference between genders (sexual dimorphism) is common in nature, the drastic disparity between male and female argonauts is unusual.
A drop in the water temperature each year ushers in the argonaut mating season. As the water cools, divers can see the number of male argonauts in the water column dramatically increase from one or two to 20 or more on a single dive. In the black of night, the males buzz around like swarms of tiny bumblebees as they search for a mate.
Sexually mature females tend to be a bit shy during the off season, when the number of sightings are minimal. In contrast, mating season happens quickly, going from a single sighting one night to multiple sightings the next as the females begin to form groups. When the beams from our dive lights pass through a group of females, they instantly scatter and shoot toward us like kamikazes, running into our cameras and heads, bouncing off and rocketing toward the surface.
Both males and females ride jellyfish, salps and other objects such as leaves, sticks and even drifting debris. Researchers have found bits of jellyfish and salp in the stomachs of nautiluses, indicating that these cephalopods can survive in the water column by feeding on plankton and other mollusks or near substrate by feeding on shrimp and crabs. Like other species of octopus, argonauts possess a venom that is passed through their saliva when they use their beaks to kill their prey.
For the best chance to see a nautilus in the wild, be in the water at night in an area where they are usually found. It might require multiple dives at different times of the year — and a little bit of luck — to see one.
CAPTURING THE SHOT
When photographing argonauts, I prefer to use a 60mm lens, ISO 400, 1/200 shutter speed and the aperture at f/18. I set my strobes at half power and position them close to the lens port.
When framing the image, watch the argonauts’ eyes for sharp contact, and be prepared to swim quickly. Argonauts are light sensitive — using a red light can help calm them down, although it is not always necessary. Using a handheld light with a tight beam can help you see through turbid water. Refrain from touching the animals; they stress easily and like most cephalopods will ink profusely.
The argonaut is now a highly valued species for blackwater divers. Given the number of paper nautiluses we have seen in such a short time, the once-rare and unique subject has become more common.
Although sightings of paper nautiluses are on the rise, they are still one of nature’s biggest mysteries and have gone mostly unnoticed for a long time. Argonauts are a fascinating spectacle and will likely leave you as they have left me: in awe of nature. AD
Posted in Alert Diver Summer Editions
Tagged with Sealife, Nautilus, Mike Bartick, phillippines, Conservation, Underwater photographer
Tagged with Sealife, Nautilus, Mike Bartick, phillippines, Conservation, Underwater photographer
Categories
2023
January
March
Demo DiversCape Marine Research and Diver DevelopmentKaboom!....The Big Oxygen Safety IssueTerrific Freedive Mode“LIGHTS, Film, Action!”Scuba Nudi ClothingDive into Freedive InstructionThe Benefits of Being BaldThe Inhaca Ocean Alliance.Special Forces DiverToughing It Out Is DangerousWhat Dive Computers Don\'t Know | PART 2
2022
January
February
UNCERTAINTY AFTER DIVING: Case Report and Recommendations #1.UNCERTAINTY AFTER DIVING: Case Report and Recommendations #2UNCERTAINTY AFTER DIVING: Case Report and Recommendations #3UNCERTAINTY AFTER DIVING: Case Report and Recommendations #4DIVERS LOSING ACCESS TO EMERGENCY CAREPreventing Breathing gas Contamination
March
When Should the Rescue Begin?Celebrating Young and Old in Turks and CaicosScuba Cylinder RundownChasing WeedsUnderwater Smartphone PhotographyAir and a SpareUnderwater Photographer: Fred BuyleBuilding Better BalanceLow-Visibility DivingMore Than a Sore ShoulderNot Only for DivingLaryngospasm and AnxietyPulmonary Hypertension and DivingTitan Meets TitanicPool Operation: Know Before you GoThe Argonaut Octopus and the jellyfishShort but Beautiful Lives
April
A Sense of PurposeMexico’s Sardine RunHigh-Pressure Hose injuriesA Hole in My HeartGoing UpConcussion and Return to DivingMarfan Syndrome Recommendations.South African Sardine Run by Walter BernardisSouth African Sardine Run By ProdiveSardine Run Port Elizabeth by ProDiveSardine Run Port St Johns by ProDiveScuba Diving In MauritiusScuba Diving in TanzaniaScuba Diving in the SeychellesScuba Diving in Nosy BeScuba Diving in MalawiScuba Diving in KenyaScuba Diving in South AfricaScuba Diving in Mozambique
May
June
July
Destination AntarticaUnconscious DiverA Little DetailDive Boat SafetyBlenny Watching 101Bonaire Inspires Hope for the Future of CoralThe Secret to Deep Freediving: Tips from 3 Female World Record HoldersEnsuring Safety in Freediving CompetitionsFour Tips For Staying Warm While Cold Water DivingAnd They Dived Happily Ever AfterFreediving Is About To Enter A New Era If Oxama Has Its SayGET BENT!The Joys and Challenges of the DeepUnderstanding The Secrets of Deep Freediving: Tips from Three National Record Holders