Sight Search

The Aftermath of Diving Incidents

Verse yourself in the legal implications of diving-related incidents and the aftermath that follows.
 
As per the words of the owner of an overseas dive charter. “When someone dies in a diving accident, the aftermath can even embroil those who were only doing their best to help.” He continues: “Because I had been involved in the failed rescue, it seemed as if I was fair game, as were others. It still rankles that, in trying to do my best, I got caught up in the legal repercussions.”

In this edition of the DAN-SA LegalNet, two diving-related incidents and their cases are discussed in order to explain their legal implications on the diving fraternity, including all divers, dive clubs and charters. The first incident describes the Tallman case, when in 2008, Mr Tallman drowned in a diving-related incident in Kleinbaai, near Gansbaai. In December 2014, six years later, the Western Cape High Court finally handed down a civil judgement.

The second case became news when, in June 2014, two technical divers, namely Peter Timm and his dive buddy, Adele Stegen, had died off the coast of Umkomaas, KwaZulu-Natal. A police spokesman confirmed that the post-mortem findings attributed their deaths to decompression illness. The police investigation continues and two inquest dockets have been opened by the Umkomaas Police Station.
The aftermath

Have you ever wondered what follows in the wake of unnatural deaths like these? A good point of reference is the well-known trial of Oscar Pistorius which was held in the High Court of Pretoria. Its intensive interrogation gives you a good idea of what a criminal trial is like. Imagine the added chaos if the crime scene had been in a dive shop, on a diving boat or at a dive site, where all the facts, including the photographs and testimonies, were diving related. Now imagine if you were one of the people who were involved in the incident or that you had assisted in the attempted rescue or recovery of the deceased diver. All of these factors make it very difficult to piece together an event that took place six years earlier (as with the Tallman case) and giving a detailed eye-witness account even more so. This is why keeping good records of incidents is essential: take photographs, make voice recordings and, as your memories start surfacing a day or two after the incident, write them down in precise detail. At best, our human memory span is quite limited and it fades over time. It is commonly said that the faintest ink is more powerful than the strongest memory, so make comprehensive notes as soon as possible after an incident has happened.

You are also welcome to contact the DAN-SA LegalNet for assistance with writing a statement. Once this statement is properly commissioned, it becomes a sworn affidavit. It is then considered as evidence and is a binding version of your recollection of events. You may then opt to hand it over to the investigating officer or to a legal representative. Sometimes this is all the evidence that is required of you. Occasionally, you may also be called upon in person to elaborate on your testimony, which indicates that more information may be required. The skipper’s log, the pre-dive plan and briefing, and even your personal dive log book may become admissible. These then become real and documentary pieces of evidence to be used in a court of law as they all contribute toward the explanation of what had occurred. 

Case law precedent

Case law sets precedent in the South African legal system. This means that the law is established by the outcomes of former cases. In certain instances, depending on which court delivers the judgement, the interpretation of the law is also binding on inferior courts. This is why legal writers often quote from case law in their writing – what happens once may be argued more readily the next time. With this in mind, let us consider the two cases in our introduction. Both of these incidents have had (and may still have) consequences for the diving industry. This is one of the reasons why the DAN-SA LegalNet is there to assist and equip you with the necessary knowledge and skills. Our greatest passion remains to promote safe and responsible diving.

In a recent DAN-SA roadshow, we referred to the Tallman case in the LegalNet presentations. It has become a due diligence benchmark in as far as the court upheld a requirement for due diligence from those who were involved in the incident [1]. Without commenting on the decision itself, certain remarks in the report deserve special mention because they are starting to narrow the legal definition of what safe diving practices are meant to be. Follow the link under the references section for access to the complete official report online.

The facts of the event are as follows: On 13 April 2008, Mr Tallman drowned in a diving-related incident in Kleinbaai, near Gansbaai. At 07:30, the vessel set out to sea on a shark-viewing expedition with 10 tourists on board. About two hours after their departure and while at anchor (with a videographer in the shark cage) the vessel was struck by a large wave that caused it to capsize, resulting in the drowning of three tourists on board, including Mr Tallman, the husband of the plaintiff.
 
Subsequently, the plaintiff instituted action against the vessel, the skipper of the vessel on that day and the owner of the vessel. The court case lasted a number of days and many witnesses were asked to testify. Even people from other vessels who answered the distress call were obliged to testify. Various specialists on the marine environment and weather conditions were also questioned.

Several issues came under intensive scrutiny, including the applicable law, the foreseeable consequences of a breaking wave when at anchor, what swell size would have indicated danger, the swell conditions before the capsize, not keeping a proper lookout, failure to depart, failure to check the depth in front of the vessel and the relative sizes of vessels and their wave tolerances. Then, after evaluating all the evidence, the learned AJ Freund made several comments that had a direct bearing on all the owners of dive charters and dive businesses, dive leaders and divers in general. He comments (paragraph 187 of the official report):

In the Court’s view the skipper and crew had become used to operating in quite large swells, and they therefore paid little attention to the swells on the day in question. They (and other skippers and crew of similar vessels who regularly visited the Geldsteen) had, in the Court’s view become complacent. It was just bad luck on the part of the Shark Team and good luck on the part of the other vessels that the only vessel struck by the wave which broke was Shark Team.
 
He continues to claim that (paragraph 188):
 
The swell conditions on the day in issue may not have been as large as they sometimes get, but they were large enough to serve as a warning of danger to a prudent skipper. The point has been made above that a prudent skipper leaves a margin of safety and does not flirt with risk.
 
The court found that in this case, the swell conditions were sufficiently large and threatening that the skipper should have foreseen that a wave breaking over their vessel was a reasonable possibility. It found the skipper to have been negligent and his negligence to be causally connected to the capsize, which caused the death. Although the court only refers to the skipper, it goes without saying that under appropriate circumstances the word “skipper” could have been substituted with “dive buddy”, “dive leader”, “dive master” or The bottom line is that we should not become complacent and that we should treat every dive outing with the necessary respect and due diligence. When diving, proper planning and record keeping are normative and therefore legally required.

Potential inquest 

Other aspects of the aftermath of such an incident are the potential inquests. In the case of a fatal incident, divers should not tamper with any of the deceased diver’s equipment; the Inquests Act, 1959 (Act No. 58 of 1959) specifically prohibits this. The integrity of the scene is very important and that of the diving equipment even more so. In terms of the act, an incident “in relation to a death” is defined as “the occurrences during which an injury which gave rise to the death was sustained or during which other occurrences which directly gave rise to the death occurred”. In the case of Peter Timm and Adele Stegen, Section two of the act makes it imperative for anyone who has reason to believe that any other person has died and that the death was due to something other than natural causes (whether a diving or a motor vehicle accident), to report it accordingly and as soon as possible to a policeman, unless he or she has reason to believe that a report has been, or will be made, by any other person. DAN-SA assures its members that, once notified of such an event, it will be reported to the local police.
 
Section four of the act is also important: “The policeman investigating the circumstances of the death or alleged death of any person shall submit a report thereon, together with all relevant statements, documents and information, to the public prosecutor, who may, if he deems necessary, call for any additional information regarding the death.” If it seems self-evident that an offence has been committed (for example murder or culpable homicide), a summons will be issued to get the accused in court. Section five states that “if criminal proceedings are not instituted in connection with the death, or alleged death, the prosecutor shall submit those statements, documents and information submitted to him to the magistrate of the district concerned”. If it appears to the magistrate that the death was due to unnatural causes, “he shall take such steps as are necessary to ensure that an inquest as to the circumstances and cause of the death is held. Any person who has a substantial and peculiar interest can be subpoenaed to give oral evidence or to produce any document or thing at such an inquest”. This includes, amongst other things, your dive log book and your dive computer. You may also require representation by an attorney or an advocate.

Then, if at any stage evidence is found that supports a different conclusion, an inquest can be re-opened if it is in the interests of justice. Any person who has a substantial and peculiar interest and has previously testified in the original inquest can be re-subpoenaed to testify and produce any document or relevant object (as mentioned in the previous paragraph). If it then seems that an offence has been committed, criminal charges may be imposed.

In the case of a missing diver, Section 16 continues by stating that, in the event that the body of the person concerned is alleged to have been destroyed or no body is found or recovered (as is not uncommon in diving fatalities) and the evidence proves beyond reasonable doubt that a death has occurred, the judicial officer holding that inquest shall record a finding upon the inquest as to:
  • The identity of the deceased;
  • The cause or likely cause of death;
  • The date of death; and
  • Whether the death was brought about by any act or omission prima facie, involving or amounting to an offence on the part of any person.
Again, if circumstances suggest an offence, a criminal summons can, once again, be issued.

Civil claims for injury, loss or damage 

All losses or deaths may not necessarily involve a crime. They may still be wrongful, however, to the extent that those who suffered the loss may make a civil claim against those who are allegedly responsible. As such, whether damaged, lost, injured or dead, a civil claim might be instituted to recover monetary damages with compensation. The South African legal system is based on the principle that it is the onus of the accuser to provide evidence. This is why people may be called upon to testify years after an event, and as with the Tallman case, the court must then apply legal principles (delictual principles) to the proven facts.

The DAN-SA LegalNet, in operation for the past two years, has been welcomed by our DAN-SA members and we have thus far received a remarkable number of enquiries. As such, DAN-SA is considering the inclusion of essential legal support services under the DAN-SA Group Policy, such as legal costs in the case of a diving accident or incident where our recreational diver members or dive buddies (excluding professional dive leaders) are exposed to civil liability, so keep an eye open for new things to come. Also, please contact us and feel free to comment on the content of this article or ask questions. We welcome all constructive criticism – contact DAN-SA at mail@dansa.org 

2 Comments


Peter Southwood - September 8th, 2016 at 12:06pm

Are we reaching the point where each diver needs to get their buddy to sign a release specifying the terms and limitations of responsibility of both parties when buddy diving? Particularly since buddy diving has such a wide range of practices, some according to the certifying agency, others not, but nevertheless in common use.

Categories

 2020
 2019
 2018
 2016
immersion and bubble formation Accidents Acid reflux Acute ailments After anaesthesia Air Quality Air exchange centre Air hose failure Airway control Air Alert Diver Magazine Alternative gas mix Altitude changes Altitude sickness Aluminium Oxide Ama divers Amino acids Anaerobic Metabolism Annual renewal Apnea Apnoea Archaeology Arterial gas embolism Arthroscopic surgery Aspirin Aurel hygiene BCD BHP BLS BWARF Back adjustment Back pain Back treatment Backextensors Badages Bag valve mask Bahamas Balancing Bandaids Barbell back squat Barometric pressure Barotrauma Basic Life Support Batteries Bench press Benign prostate hyperplasia Beth Neale Black Blood flow Blood thinners Blue Wilderness Blurred vision Boat safety Bone fractures Bouyancy compensators Boyle's Law Boyle\'s Law Bradycardia Brain Breast Cancer Breath Hold Diving Breath holding Breath hold Breath-hold Breathing Gas Breathing gas contamination Breathing Breathold diving Broken bones Bruising Bubbleformation Buddy Exercise Buddy checks Buoyancy Burnshield CGASA CMAS CO2 COVID-19 COVID CPR Cabin pressure Caissons diseas Camera settings Cancer Remission Cancer treatments Cancer Cannabis and diving Cannabis Cape Town Dive Festival Cape Town CapeTown Carbon Monoxide Carbon dioxide Cardio health Cardiological Cardiomyopathy Chamber Safety Chamber science Charging batteries Charles' Law Charles\' Law Charles\\\' Law Charles\\\\\\\' Law Charles\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\' Law Charlie Warland Chemotherapy Chest compressions Chiropractic Chlorophll Citizen Conservation Cleaning products Coastalexcursion Cold Water Cold care ColdWater Cold Commercial diving Commercial schools Compressed Air Compressed gas Consercation Conservation Contaminants Contaminated air Coral Conservation Coral Reefs Coral bleaching Corals Core strength Corona virus Courtactions Crohns disease Crowns Crystal build up Crystallizing hoses Cutaneous decompression DAN Courses DAN Profile DAN Researchers DAN medics DAN members DAN report DCI DCS Decompressions sickness DCS theories DCS DEMP DM training DNA DReams Dalton's Law Dalton\'s Law Dalton\\\'s Law Dalton\\\\\\\'s Law Dalton\\\\\\\\\\\\\\\'s Law Danel Wenzel Dauin island Dean's Blue Hole Deco dives Decompression Illness Decompression Sickness Decompression Stress Decompression illsnes Decompression treatment Decompression Deep diving Deep water exploration Delayed Offgassing Dental Diaphragms Diseases Dive Chamber Dive Computer Dive Destinations Dive H Dive Industry Dive Instruction Dive Instructor Dive Medical Form Dive Medical Dive Pros Dive Research Dive South Africa Dive Training Dive Travel Dive accidents Dive buddies Dive computers Dive excursions Dive fitness Dive gear Dive heallth Dive health Dive medicines Dive medicine Dive operators Dive planning Dive safety Dive safe Dive staff DiveLIVE Diveleader training Diveleaders Diver Health Diver Profile Diver infliencers Diver on surface Divers Alert Diving Divas Diving Kids Diving Trauma Diving career Diving emergencies Diving emergency management Diving fit Diving guidelines Diving injuries Diving suspended Diving Dizziness Dolphins Domestic Donation Dowels Dr Rob Schneider Drysuit diving Drysuit valves Drysuits Dyperbaric medicines EAPs EAP Ear pressure Ear wax Ears injuries Eco friendly Education Electronic Emergency action planning Emergency decompression Emergency plans Emergency underwater Oxygen Recompression Emergency Enviromental Protection Environmental factors Environmental impact Environmental managment Equalisation Equipment care Evacuations Evacuation Evaluations Even Breath Exercise Exhaustion Extended divetime Extinguisher Extreme treatments Eye injuries FAQ Factor V Leiden Failures Fatigue Faulty equipment Female divers Fillings Fire Coral Fire Safety Firefighting First Aid Equipment First Aid Kit First Aid Training First Aid kits Fish Identification Fish Fitness Training Fitness to dive Fitness Flying Fractures Francois Burman Fredive Free Student cover Free diving Free flow Freedive INstructor Freedive Training Freediver Freediving performance Freediving Gas Density Gas consumption Gas laws Gas mixes GasPerformance Gases Gastoeusophagus Gastric bypass Gastroenterologist Gear Servicing Gordon Hiles Great White Sharks Gutt irritations HCV HELP HIRA HMS Britanica Haemorhoid treatment Hazard Description Hazardous Marine life Hazardous marinelife Health practitioner Heart Attack Heart Health Heart Rate monitor Heart rates Heart rate Heart Heat stress Helium Hepatitis C Hepatitus B High temperatures Hip strength Hip surgery Hippocampus History Hot Humans Hydrate Hydration Hydrogen Hydroids Hydrostatic pressure Hyperbaric Chamber Hyperbaric research Hyperbarics Hypothermia Hypoxia IdentiFin Immersion Immine systems In Water Recompression Indemnity form Indian Ocean Indonesia Inert gas Infections Infra red Imaging Injections Instinct Instruction Instructors Insurance Integrated Physiology International travel International Interval training Irritation Joint pain Junior Open Water Diver KZN South Coast Kidneys Kids scubadiver KwaZulu Natal Labour laws Laryngospasm Lauren Arthur Learning to dive Legal advice Legislation Leukemis Liability Risks Liability releases Liability Life expectancy Lifestyle Lightroom editing Live aboard diving Liver Toxicity Liver diseas Low blood pressure Low pressure deterioration Low volume masks Lung Irritation Lung function Lung injuries Lung squeeze Lung surgery Lung MOD Maintenance Malaria Mammalian Dive Response Mammalian effect Marine Biology Marine Scientists Marine conservation Marine parks Marinelife Masks Master scuba diver Maximum operating depth Medical Q Medical emergencies Medical questionaire Medical statement Medication Mehgan Heaney-Grier Mermaid Danii Mesophotic Middle ear pressure Mike Bartick Military front press Mixed Gas Mono Fins Mooring lines More pressure Motion sickness Mozambique Muscle pain Mycobacterium marinum Nausea Nautilus Neck pain Neurological assessments Nitrogen Narcosis Nitrogen build up Nitrox No-decompression Non-rebreather Mask Normal Air Nosebleeds O2 providers O2 servicing OOxygen maintenance Ocean Research Ocean pollution Oil contamination Open water divers Orbital implants Oronasal mask Osteonecrosis Out and about Outreach Oxygen Cylinder Oxygen Units Oxygen deficit Oxygen deicit Oxygen dificiency Oxygen ears Oxygen equipment Oxygen masks Oxygen supply Oxygen therapy Oxygen P J Prinsloo PFI PJP Tech Part 3 Partner Training Philippine Islands Philippines Phillipines Photography Physioball Physiology Physiotherapy Pills Pistons Planning Plastic Pneumonia Pneumothorax Poison Pollution Pool Diving Post-dive Pre-dive Predive check Preparation Prepared diver Press Release Professional rights Provider course Psycological Pulmanologist Pulmonary Bleb Pulmonary Edema Pulse Punture wounds Pure Apnea Purge RAID South Africa RCAP REEF Radio communications Range of motion Rashes Rebreather diving Rechargeable batteries. Recompression chamber Recompression treatment Recompression Recycle Reef Conservation Reef surveyors Regulator failure Regulators Regulator Remote areas Renewable Report incidents Rescue Procedure Rescue breathing Rescue breaths Rescue training Rescue Resume diving Return to diving Risk Assessments Risk assesments Risk assessment Risk elements Risk management SABS 019 SafariLive Safety Stop Safety SaherSafe Barrier Salty Wanderer Sanitising Sara Andreotti Saturation Diving Save our seas Science Scombroid Poisoning Scuba Air Quality Scuba Injury Scuba Instructor Scuba children Scuba dive Scuba health Scubalearners Sea Horses Sealife Shark Protection Shark Research Shark conservation Shark diving Sharks Shoulder strength Sideplank Signs and Symptoms Sit-ups Skin Bends Skin outbreak Skin rash Snorkeling Snorkels Social Distancing Sodwana Bay Solomon Islands South Africa Spinal pain Splits Squeezes Stability exercise Standars Stay Fit Stents Step ups Stepping up Stroke Submerged Sudafed Sulawesi Supplemental oxygen Surface supplied Air Surfaced Surgeries Surgery Suspension training TRavel safety Tabata protocol Talya Davidoff Tattoes Technical Diving The Bends The truth Thermal Notions Tides Tips and trick Tooth squeeze Transplants Travel smarter Travel tips Travel Tropical Coastal Management Tunnelling Tweezers Ultrsound Umkomaas Unconsciousness Underground work Underwater hockey Underwater photographer Underwater photography Underwater pho University of Stellenbosch Urinary retention. Vaccines Vagus nerve Valsalva manoeuvers Vape Vaping Vasopressors Vasvagal Syncope Venting Virus infections Volatile fuels Washout treatments Wastewater Watchman device Water Resistance Water Weakness Weigang Xu Weights West Papua Wet diving bell Wetsuit fitting Wetsuits White balance Wide angles Winter Woman in diving Woman Women In Diving SA Women in diving Work of Breathing Workout Wound dressings Wreck divers Wreck dive Wreckdiving Wrecks Yoga Youth diver Zandile Ndholvu Zoology abrasion acoustic neuroma excision air-cushioned alert diver altitude anemia antibiotics anticoagulants antiseptics bandages barodontalgia bent-over barbell rows bioassays body art breathing air calories burn carbon dioxide toxicity cardiovascular cerebrospinal fluid checklist chemo port child clearances closed circuit scuba currents cuts dead lift decompression algorithms decongestants decongestion dehydration dive injuries dive medicing dive ready child dive reflex dive tribe diver in distress diver rescue diver training dive diving attraction doctors domestic travel dri-suits drowning dry mucous membranes dry suits dry e-cigarettes ear spaces elearning electrolyte imbalance electroytes emergency action plans emergency assessment equalising equalizing exposure injuries eyes fEMAL DIVERS fire rescue fitnes flexible tubing frediving freedivers gas bubble gas poisoning gastric acid gene expression health heartburn histidine hospital humidity immersion and bubble formation immersion pulmonary edema (IPE jaundice join DAN knee longevity lower stress malaise marine pathogens medical issues medical procedures medical risk assesment medications mental challenge micro-organisims minor illness mucous membranes nasal steroids nasal near drowning nematocysts neurological newdivers nitrogen bubbles off-gassed operating theatre operations orthopeadic outgas pain perforation phillippines physical challenges pinched nerves plasters polyester-TPU polyether-TPU post dive posture preserve prevention psychoactive pulmunary barotrauma rebreather mask rebreathers retinal detachment risk areas safety stops saturation scissors scuba equipment scuba single use sinus infections smoking snorkeling. spearfishing sterilising stings strength sub-aquatic swimmers ears tattoo care tecnical diver thermal protection toxicity training trimix unified standards vision impaired warmers water quality